Rob Brooks-Bilson
Tech, Photography, Stuff
Tech, Photography, Stuff
October 10, 2004
Since MAX falls over Election Day in the US this year, many of us will be voting by absentee/early ballot. I'm currently residing in Arizona, and just received my ballot the other day. Remembering all of the problems with ballots during the 2000 election, I decided to read the instructions VERY carefully.
You would think that with the Florida fiasco still fresh on everyone's mind, states would take a lot more care in designing their ballots and the included instructions. Well, it looks like that isn't the case, at least in Arizona.
I was shocked and utterly amazed that my ballot and the accompanying instructions contain completely contradictory information. It boils down to this: the included instructions state that the ballot should be filled out using a No. 2 pencil (this is in both English and Spanish). However, printed on the ballot itself (in English only, as the entire ballot is English only) is an instruction to "USE BLACK BALLPOINT PEN. DO NOT USE FELT TIP PEN.” Now I'm not sure which instruction is actually the correct one, and I'm not sure that it really matters, but if it does, a lot of Spanish speaking voters in Arizona are going to be disenfranchised.
Before I actually send in my early ballot tomorrow, I'm going to give the Maricopa County Elections Department a call for clarification.
Update: Well, looks like you can use either a No. 2 pencil, or ablack ballpoint pen. Here's a decent article on the Phoenix New Times web site that does some decent reporting on the early voting problems in Arizona.
10/10/04 5:54 PM
Damn, what a mess...I'm wondering if my ballot will ever show up. I moved at just the wrong time for changing my registration from one area of Pennsylvania to the other. Oh well - regardless of outcome, at least we'll be in the right place to celebrate or drink ourselves into a blissful ignorance.
10/10/04 9:14 PM
It's worthy to take a look on what Brazil is doing with eletronic elections:
http://www.wired.com/news/business/0,1367,61654,00...
I can tell: it's really safe, fast and nice. Chances are that in 2006, will be possible to vote via Internet, just like we already do with many things such as income taxes and other governmental obligations.
10/11/04 5:39 AM
When I went to go do early voting in my county (you can’t get a ballet in the mail – you have to go in!) I was surprised to see that, not only were we still using the butterfly ballots made so famous in Florida, but I was only given a print-out of who to vote for and what number to punch. So rather than flipping the pages of the butterfly book and looking at the names of each candidate, I had to look at the printout and compare the numbers to the empty book. The instructions were only in English (I didn’t ask if Spanish was available). While this wasn’t really that much of a challenge, I’m really surprised that it wasn’t chanced after Florida. I guess the elections board of the state of Illinois figures Champaign County is voting pretty strongly Democrat; it doesn’t matter if all the votes are quite right.
10/18/04 10:04 AM
Check out the update to my post, and the linked article on additional voting problems in Arizona.
10/18/04 9:49 PM
Thanks for checking into the pen/pencil issue. I too was wondering the same thing when I got my ballot on Friday. I called the elections office only to get a voicemail of some sort. I am wondering how many early voters will be confused by the pen/pencil issue and how many will not send it their ballot because they think they did it wrong? You would think that an oversight such as that wouldn't happen - I mean making your instructions match isn't all that hard is it?
Anyway, thanks a bunch.